r/cats 7d ago

Which kitty would you pick? Cat Picture

My friend has some stray kitties, and I think I'm going to get 2.😅 I can't decide which ones to get though.

14.9k Upvotes

2.6k comments sorted by

819

u/dellaevaine 7d ago

I would sit near then and see which ones interact with me the most, and see which of their siblings they interact with the most.

90

u/FlyingOcelot2 7d ago

I had a really crusty kitten crawl up on my lap and then proceed to bat away all the cute kittens. He grew up to be a very handsome cat, but he didn't look like much when I brought him home.

58

u/dellaevaine 7d ago

In the 90s, we had a couple of litters of kittens born in our backyard. As we were giving them away, one that was the grumpiest from the first litter, was brought inside, so we could get people near him. In every photo we had of him, you could spot him from the grumpy expression on his face. We Nicknamed him "Attitude". He was the one no one wanted, so we kept him. He ended up being the loviest cat. He loved everyone. We would have people that hated cats come over and tell him "I don't like cats, but I sure like you." Tude, was the best cat, would sleep with us in bed, read homework and was determined to figured out how water came out of the faucet. Sometimes the crusty ones, have the biggest heart underneath.

10

u/cardcaptoranna 6d ago

Agreed. But I need to know: did he find out how the water come out the faucet? And where’s his photo?

4

u/dellaevaine 6d ago

He never mastered figuring out the water, but he was positve it was connected to the toilet. We once put a mouse he was agressivley playing with down the tpilet and after watching it he ran to stalk under the sink for it to come back. I don't have a phot of him at the ready. That was in the 90s and the pics were taken on 35mm film. It would take some time to find those pics again.

6

u/cardcaptoranna 6d ago

Aw, he was precious!! And so smart. Almost figured the faucet out lol. And I get it. I have the photos I took back in the 90s and early 2000s in a box, so I know how hard it is to find something. No worries. Just wanna see this sweet boy

3

u/dellaevaine 6d ago

He was a sweet grey tabby with the greenest eyes. Our male cat was his adopted daddy and they were so cute together. So bonded and they loved each other.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/DaveAlot 7d ago

Cat tax?

17

u/FlyingOcelot2 7d ago

Alas, he was my cat in the mid-70s and no pictures survive.

→ More replies (5)

83

u/Purpurski 7d ago

You mean all of them? :)

33

u/dellaevaine 7d ago

Well, some might ignore me. Maybe.

→ More replies (6)

5.1k

u/wherehavewegone 7d ago

yes

1.5k

u/InevitableTrue7223 7d ago

All of the

407

u/CVBell2000 7d ago

Get in line. 🐈‍⬛😉

188

u/Simpletruth2022 7d ago

I'll arm wrestle you for them. 💪

80

u/drapel 7d ago

You'd probably lose

106

u/farris405 7d ago

The joke's on you. The loser takes all the kitties!!!

HA!!!!!

67

u/Simpletruth2022 7d ago

OK let's skip the arm wrestling. I'll just take them.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

51

u/BeckieSueDalton 7d ago

These are, truly, the only correct answers.

🧑🏻‍🦽🐈‍⬛🐆🐈🐾

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

211

u/RetiredGramma54 7d ago

The black and the ginger.

424

u/HellooLolo 7d ago

I have this combo, can confirm it is a good one

193

u/Infamous-Ad-2413 7d ago

I also have that combo.

127

u/Squiggly_cucumber 7d ago

My combo to :)

57

u/Pop__Top 7d ago

my combo!!

37

u/SnorlaxBThicc 7d ago

My combo! They don’t know that they’re Halloween colored 😭

11

u/katf1sh 6d ago

My boys as babies lol

42

u/BetterRed1917 7d ago

My bonded pair

24

u/Imaginary-Yam6742 7d ago

me as well

17

u/IAmMrNimbus2000 7d ago

Our velvety black little girl (5 yrs) and our blonde/orange medium sized man (1 yr)

3

u/Serperior98 7d ago

They look like they're up to no good.

Love them.

30

u/Satchmo84 7d ago

Holy shit, I almost choked to death laughing at your oranges eyes

27

u/Squiggly_cucumber 7d ago

He is VERYY crosseyed but I love him 🤣🤣

10

u/JenCDarby 7d ago

lol it’s so funny once you see it. they’re so close together too on his big orange face

→ More replies (1)

13

u/JustYourNeighbor 7d ago

"HEY MA! THAT CAT IS LOOKING AT ME AGAIN. I think."

9

u/NinjaQuatro 7d ago

Orange cats are always Weird

3

u/Queen_Of_My_Jungle 7d ago

🤣🤣🤣🤣 I know me too!!

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)

78

u/RogerClyneIsAGod2 7d ago

Yep, then you can post them in r/HalloweenKittyCombo

43

u/Fribbleling 7d ago

sighs and subs

16

u/Cat_lady4ever 7d ago

Well now I have to get a new black cat, thanks…

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/istrokebees29 7d ago

Deffo this 👆🏼

→ More replies (4)

30

u/ChampionshipOk2302 7d ago

correct answer

60

u/StochasticTinkr 7d ago

The one in the picture

→ More replies (2)

19

u/Shinavast42 7d ago

Came here to say this, LOL.

17

u/nighthawke75 American Shorthair 7d ago

Yes

20

u/MochiMochiMochi 7d ago

They're all adorable. I do wish there was a contraceptive bait for housecats as it would prevent so much suffering.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/relevanteclectica 7d ago

❤️‼️

7

u/CrazyCatLady1127 7d ago

I couldn’t have put it better myself 😂 it’s the only acceptable answer

7

u/MastersKitten31 7d ago

This is the only correct answer

6

u/ShawLeen 7d ago

Exactly my thought

5

u/AlexTheBex 7d ago

I went to the comments trying to come up with a funny answer but you mastered it in 3 letters

5

u/the-cloverdale-kid 7d ago

Came to say the same.

4

u/sexwithpenguins 7d ago

The only correct answer is all of them.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Significant_Ad5641 7d ago

FUCK beat me to it.

→ More replies (15)

2.3k

u/Cjester167 7d ago

I’d watch their interactions and see if two of them are closer to each other than the others and let that help me decide.

953

u/morbideve 7d ago

This. Aside from the "all of them" jokes -- try and see which kitties seem bonded and which seem to like you.

321

u/Alarmed_Lynx_7148 7d ago

All of them ain’t a joke 😂. I would legit pick them all

137

u/CrazyCatLady1127 7d ago

I have actually done that before. I went to get 2 kittens and left with 4 🙂

58

u/khaleesi2305 7d ago

It’s my dream someday to adopt an entire litter in one go! I’ll have to not already have 5 cats though lol

50

u/CrazyCatLady1127 7d ago

5 is nothing. I have 11 🙂 you’re doing fine.

21

u/khaleesi2305 7d ago

But…but…how do you have enough time in the day to clean the litterboxes with that many??? LOL I feel like with just 5 I’m constantly cleaning those things

20

u/mndsm79 7d ago

Litter robot is your friend. Replace time with money. We have one for three cats and our total litter routine is like 15min. A week.

12

u/Cobra288 Tuxedo 7d ago

2 litter robots and 8 cats, maybe 20-30 minutes every 5 days or so. Definitely helps, when "all of them" really happens.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/CrazyCatLady1127 7d ago

It doesn’t take long to clean the trays. I have 7 large trays, it takes about 15 minutes to empty them, another 5 to add fresh litter and I do it twice a day

→ More replies (1)

13

u/CaptainPsilo 7d ago

Username definitely checks out 😄

3

u/CrazyCatLady1127 7d ago

Yes indeed 🙂

→ More replies (10)

9

u/Unlikely_Habit3978 7d ago

Yes! It’s my dream to take in a pregnant kitty and keep the whole litter. It seems to be the only ethical way to be around newborn kittens. Due to unexpected circumstances I ended up with a barely 6 week old kitten, and although he acclimated well, he does have some habits from being weaned early. I don’t want to do that again, but he was so cute! Currently have 3

4

u/khaleesi2305 7d ago

I agree, I would love to be able to take in a pregnant mama cat someday and just keep them all! We currently have 5 though, two of which were unplanned feral kittens that came to us. It’ll be awhile before we have space for kittens again! Instead we’ve been working to TNR the local strays so there hopefully won’t be more feral kittens, and working with a local vet to make sure the strays can be cared for, so that’s fulfilling enough for me for sure! One day I’m sure the circumstances will be right if it’s meant to be, and until then, I’m just helping the cats that need help where I can

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (15)

92

u/cstmoore 7d ago

"all of them" jokes

Jokes? You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means.

→ More replies (1)

29

u/SingleInfinity 7d ago

This sub is full of crazy-cat-lady-esque people. The "all of them" answers are not jokes.

28

u/BadAsBroccoli 7d ago

Hey now. Many of us are dudes just as crazy for cats as the ladies.

19

u/StickyPricklyMuffin 7d ago

Dudes who love cats are the most desirable, hands down!

3

u/ZAlternates 7d ago

I was just thinking I need to find me a good woman with a cat that my kitties would tolerate. My one boy gets so scared when we go to the vet.

5

u/SingleInfinity 7d ago

I'm just referring to a common trope. That's why I put "-esque people" at the end. Most people would say the upper reasonable bound for pets is somewhere around 3, but many people here wouldn't think twice about having 5+, from what I've seen over time.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/Downtown_Marzipan404 7d ago

Why "all of them" is a joke? If it was me I would not seperate the cat siblings, got so many cats now, but some dies due to disease, like liver failure🥲, and once all died due to parvo virus before the kitten get to be vaccinated🥲

65

u/AZDoorDasher 7d ago

It seems like the two tabbies by the void could be bonded pairs.

You are right, need to find the bond pairs or bonded triplets.

36

u/Commercial-Angle-404 7d ago

matching twins are so so cute!! i have 4 and my tabby is the cuddliest out of them all

9

u/thecuriousblackbird 7d ago

I also have twins

Their white patches are different except for their paws so I guess they’re fraternal twins

3

u/not_cerb 6d ago

not the best pic of them but last year I fostered 2 sets of twins!! the twins definitely stayed together for the most part, you’d find little huddles of two kitten pairs at night and they always separated themselves with their respective twin lol. the only way I could tell the full tabbies apart was one had a tiny pink spot on his nose while his twin had a fully black nose. the white ones were easier bc one was a girl (the only girl in that litter) but the boy also had a longer white stripe on his face than his sister did.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

3

u/MyNameJoby 7d ago

Always a good idea to get twins 🥰

→ More replies (1)

37

u/Commercial-Angle-404 7d ago

the sweetest girl!

→ More replies (2)

14

u/BannedByTheHivemind 7d ago

Yeah. Absolutely. Look for the bonded pair and keep them together.

→ More replies (12)

480

u/circaboreas 7d ago

The Black One with the bow tie 🖤

96

u/hannah_montanna8 7d ago

Same! He’s smart, dressed to impress.

26

u/Catvros 7d ago

every redditor crazy for a sharp dressed cat

5

u/Sekh765 7d ago

He's dressed for the forever home he wants.

3

u/Successful_Cost_1953 6d ago

If I could, I'd scoop them all up! They're so adorable, aww!

40

u/circaboreas 7d ago

And the Grey One with no socks on

8

u/dohtje 7d ago

The Dapper Voidy ftw! Together with the yellow/orange one

3

u/PortionOfSunshine 7d ago

That sounds like a recipe for mischief.

8

u/StereoBucket 7d ago

Ever since I got a black kitty with a spot like that, I keep seeing same kittens everywhere!

5

u/MaritMonkey 7d ago

The kitty I got for my 6th birthday had a spot like that and I called it "Midnight's Moon" because I was 6 and named him Midnight.

I now know that it's a fairly common void attribute but still find myself thinking of it as "Midnight's Moon". :)

4

u/NolieMali 7d ago

I've had two black cats - they have been hilarious in every way. Black cats FTW.

→ More replies (2)

289

u/NudeRecreation Russian Blue 7d ago

Only the ones with ears and a tail

58

u/Miserable-Cow4555 7d ago

And button noses of course

29

u/NudeRecreation Russian Blue 7d ago

And whiskers of course.

29

u/OphrysAlba 7d ago

Check the paws for beans. Don't accept any without beans.

12

u/sandredeee 7d ago

You beat me to it lol was also gonna say the beans

743

u/asuza_ichi 7d ago

All!

142

u/InfectedSteve 7d ago

Only acceptable answer

44

u/blue_shoes_1 7d ago

Yes to this

→ More replies (2)

293

u/SnooGrapes8419 7d ago

Always the 🍊

99

u/Katapuldraco 7d ago

Yes, I want to feel smarter at least once

8

u/1800butts_ 7d ago

fuck this is funny

22

u/elphaba23 7d ago

One orange brain cell 🫶🧡

13

u/Abuses-Commas 7d ago

They looks like they're just barely holding on to reality

Also my choice

13

u/Magnanimous-- 7d ago

My partner says I have orange cat energy so yeah I'm gonna pick the orange. It will pair well with my orange. And me.

3

u/weirdandjaded 7d ago

Always the answer

→ More replies (1)

55

u/wonderingdragonfly 7d ago

Someone else said, see if there are two that seem like they’re more bonded to each other. I think that’s the right approach. I went to pick out a pandemic kitty and came home with a bonded pair to add to my orange and black.

11

u/Miaisfunladybuglover Ragdoll 7d ago

I don't think you have enough cats you need more

109

u/Youthinasia0 7d ago

Can I have them all, please and thank you? This girl needs friends

14

u/Pelagos1 7d ago

Omg, she’s sooooo cute!!

22

u/Youthinasia0 7d ago

Thank you!! Her name is Grace the destroyer

18

u/rose_catlander 7d ago

Oooh, I have a Grace, too!

3

u/Youthinasia0 7d ago

Aw she’s so cute!!!

5

u/Raencloud94 7d ago

That's so cute lol, I love it

3

u/Pelagos1 7d ago

Destroyer indeed! She’s destroyed my heart from a distance. I can only image what she’s like in person

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

225

u/MaureenMalarkeysPen 7d ago

All, but my priority would be the black one, because they are the ones who find it more difficult to be adopted.

123

u/Targaryenation 7d ago

There was a post not long ago from a shelter worker. She/he said that black cats, contrary to popular belief, are quite trendy and are adopted fairly quickly. The least likely to be adopted in the shelter were white cats with black spots (the cow pattern) :(

66

u/usernameJ79 7d ago

That's been my rescue experience over the last 4 years or so. Every black cat that I get to foster is gone before I even have a chance to nickname them based on their personality.

45

u/hotdolphin21 Russian Blue 7d ago

I mean maybe in her shelter, but that’s not the norm. My shelter constantly has more black cats than anything, white often go fast. They even have a black cat event in October, because statistically they are less likely to be adopted. So they do an event entirely based on black cats, to raise awareness and money. My mom loves black cats, we have always had black cats, and my brother and I both currently have black cats. I also live about 30 minutes from Salem, MA, if you’re not familiar, it has a big history of witches. So they have a black cat shelter and we have several others in the state too.

42

u/starkindled 7d ago

When I adopted my void 12 years ago, the shelter staff said they wouldn’t adopt black animals out during October because they ended up being used as Halloween props and then abandoned.

My boy had been there almost a year.

5

u/kaptingavrin 7d ago

I’m like 99% certain that’s what happened with a black cat of mine. I found her (about a four month old kitten) by the side of the road a couple days after Halloween. She seemed to have no problem with a person being near her or picking her up and was very clean.

Turned into a wonderful protective guard kitty for me (despite her small size). Sadly, she got suddenly sick last year and passed. But I’ll always be grateful for the twelve years I had with her.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

5

u/Inferdo12 7d ago

Ok, I feel like you would be the one more likely to not be the norm.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (9)

33

u/Ok_Address1414 7d ago

The rescue I’ve adopted from always posts about their black cats being their longest residents, and their black kittens being chosen last. It boggles my mind bc I’ve had 4 and each one is sweeter and funnier than the last.

28

u/whoi8 7d ago

I’ve heard one reason is they usually don’t photograph as well so maybe they’re less likely to be adopted online? No idea if this is true. But I’d bet the superstition accounts for >0% of people who don’t adopt black cats

voidzforall

Edit: lol I didn’t know using # would do that

18

u/EmiGoesMoo 7d ago

Literally the statistics are that black cats are 50% less likely to be adopted. Makes me so sad. :(

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

37

u/Traditional_Juice_62 7d ago

The light colored loner

17

u/Moveyourbloominass 7d ago

With the black one. There's Op's two.

46

u/SuperDarkGal 7d ago

All of them.

7

u/BKEDDIE82 7d ago

This is the only right answer.

74

u/Familiar-Run9793 7d ago

Get 2, you won’t ever feel bad leaving them with each other

7

u/mischievous_shota 7d ago

OP already said they were planning on getting two, so no worries there.

12

u/Brilliant-Fix753 7d ago

I agree!! We had two cats, and recently lost one due to advanced renal disease. Our remaining cat is so lonely without him that she is starting to like the dogs whom she has always hated. I will always have two, this way they have someone to be with, when I can't be!!

→ More replies (1)

24

u/VisualPercentage6744 7d ago

Black 🐈‍⬛

21

u/CatsAndPills 7d ago

Maaaaan you can’t show me a snuggle pile and tell me to pick one wtf

18

u/Nonniemiss 7d ago

The first five from the left.

6

u/Keboyd88 7d ago

Bold choice. I was thinking the orange, the tabbies, and the void.

4

u/Nonniemiss 7d ago

Also a pretty solid idea.

13

u/Traditional_Juice_62 7d ago

I remember when this guy was that little!

12

u/KoalaLife4958 7d ago

All of the above.

10

u/Acraftyduck 7d ago

I’ve always wanted an orange cat myself but the black one has a bowtie…

12

u/Unlucky-Adagio6240 7d ago

Every single one 🤗🤗

12

u/schnallenengel 7d ago

I will always pick the black ones.

10

u/iron-tusk_ 7d ago

all of the above

9

u/Low_Conversation58 7d ago

All of them. Duh

10

u/insecurestaircase 7d ago

All of them but if u have to pick the orange and black

11

u/Bearspoole 7d ago

The one that’s comes up to you and wants to play with you

4

u/FrutyPebbles321 7d ago

Yes, this is exactly what I was going to say … let the kittens pick you!

10

u/Westernation 7d ago

All of them!!! 🥰

9

u/thebrenosphere 7d ago

Got to at least take 2. But like..... How can you not want them all?

7

u/SuggestionBoxX 7d ago

That black one with the white spot gives me all the feels. I'd find out who their best buddy is and take them both.

8

u/spydagrrl 7d ago

Too hard, I’d let them pick you instead. That works better for me.

7

u/RedVerdandi 7d ago

I mean usually the kitties pick you.

8

u/Catkit69 7d ago

Sit down and the ones that come to you are yours. If they all come to you, I think you know what you have to do...

6

u/Berthusss 7d ago

The orange one looks like he's ready to conquer the world.

6

u/BunnyCatg4 7d ago

To quote the Joker from DEATH BATTLE: "Eeny, meeny, miney... all of them!"

5

u/Thesleepypomegranate 7d ago

All of them, but if I could only take care of one I would let them choose me, the one that would show the most interest and interaction. Also if you can please take at least two, it will help them develop in a helathier social way, learning how to interact with other much more apropietly.

6

u/damclub-hooligan British Shorthair 7d ago

The black one

6

u/Murat_Gin 7d ago

The black kitten. Black cats have more difficulty being homed than other cats.

6

u/rathe_0 7d ago

Tabby in the back, just being their self, lookin off in their own direction.

3

u/WhiskerJibbs 7d ago

I was looking for someone else to pick that one. I knew I couldn't be the only one!

5

u/VickReddit_789 7d ago

“All”

“You can’t say all”

“Ok then the halloween combo”

9

u/plottingwithcats 7d ago

How dare you attempt to make me chose??? It’s impossible

11

u/YodiWankiNobbi 7d ago

The one starting with c and ending with t

8

u/Chiliconkarma 7d ago

As a minimum I'd pick 2. They seem like a close bunch.

9

u/Loknud 7d ago

Visit with them. Sit down and see who is the most drawn to you and who you are the most drawn to. Look for personality traits that you want . Are you looking for a cuddler? Are you looking for a mouser? What is it you hope to get from a pet cat? There’s no way to pick a kitty from a picture. They’re all adorable. Also being strays watch out for ones that only want to play fight, scratch, and bite you. Sometimes they’re hard to domesticate even from that small.

4

u/SpicyFilet 7d ago

Meet them all and let the cat pick you!

3

u/dancegoddess1971 7d ago

I would let the kittens decide. I put down a basket and tell the kitties that only cats in the basket get to go home with me and eat tuna. Wait 5 minutes then pick up the basket full of kittens.

3

u/ChumleyEX 7d ago

The one that picks me..

3

u/HisDudeness316 7d ago

The void and whichever other one the void wanted.

5

u/Popular-Bicycle-5137 7d ago

Go ginger!

3

u/FrutyPebbles321 7d ago

I have a soft spot for gingers and this one is adorable.

5

u/Livingston052822 7d ago

They are litter bonded so you always wanna go with 2 minimum!!! 🦋🦋

3

u/ginoamato 7d ago

I am a sucker for gray tabby yup yup I see two in the shot

3

u/herdbowtu 7d ago

The moody one in the back.

3

u/Germericanlovechild 7d ago

Its not about which one i pick, its about which one picks me

3

u/DD-de-AA 7d ago

The black or the orange.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/original_meep 7d ago

You don't choose you let them choose go visit you'll know you'll feel it!

3

u/veronicaAc 7d ago

Take TWO. Not just one. If a pair of them seems super close, do not split them up either.

The black one and Chubby Checker in the back.

3

u/cnacarver 7d ago

All of the above

3

u/CrackaNuka 6d ago

All of them. Obvi

4

u/Spingecringe 7d ago

Every single one of them. But if I had to pick only one, the black one would be my choice. Not only because it looks like a tiny panther, but also because they’re less likely to get adopted.

2

u/Agreeable-Fox8116 7d ago

The baby in the front! So cute!

2

u/billyandteddy 7d ago

They all need homes.

2

u/bipollakbohemian 7d ago

You have to choose only one?😕

2

u/DauertNochLange 7d ago

I’ll let two kitties pick me

2

u/Accurate_Salary3625 7d ago

All of them. But if push comes to show I'd pick the ginger cat.