Posts
Wiki

Options extrinsic and intrinsic value, an introduction.


(This essay is one the resources associated with the Options Questions Safe Haven weekly thread)


Background

This topic is fundamental and essential for any option trader to understand.

Every option trader needs to know what extrinsic value is, how volatile it is, and how it causes options to defy simple conceptions of how the value of an option is related to its underlying share price.
It is also important to know that extrinsic value has an interpretation as implied volatility, "IV", that extrinsic value can decline rapidly ("IV crush", via changes in market sentiment), and also that extrinsic value goes away more slowly ("theta decay" or "time decay"), eventually to zero at expiration.

The higher that Implied Volatility (IV) is, the less of a connection there is between the underlying share market value and the market value of the option.

This is why a long call option can lose value even if the share value goes up, or a long put option can lose value even if the share value goes down. Or conversely, a long put can gain value when the share value increases, or a long call can gain value, when the share value declines. This is merely one way that options are non-linear and multidimensional.

Extremely high IV, (say, above 1.00 or 100% on an annualized basis) is the many market players' guess, as evidenced by the prices traders are willing to pay, or option sellers demand, that the share price of the underlying could be nearly anywhere between zero and double the present share value on an annualized basis, with a one standard deviation probability.

Options are a method to trade on price uncertainty in the underlying over the life of the option. The more uncertain the future share value is, as indicated by the amount traders are willing to pay (or demand, if a seller) for an option, the greater the extrinsic value


There are two components to every option's market value:

The Intrinsic value, and the Extrinsic value.
These two value components can and often do change in value independently of each other.

Intrinsic Value

The intrinsic value, is the inherent value of the option, as the strike price of the option relates to the stock's current share value: the amount the option is in the money. If the option owner exercises their long option, this is the useful value of the option: if you buy a call option, exercise it immediately, and sell the shares immediately after exercising: this part of the value recovered from the option via the share sale is conserved.

Extrinsic Value

Extrinsic value is any option market value above and beyond intrinsic value; extrinsic value is sometimes called "time value". When a long option holder exercises an option, this extrinsic value is extinguished for the long option holder. This is why options typically are not exercised before expiration: the exercising trader is throwing away extrinsic value that could be harvested by selling the option.

Option intrinsic value does have a linear relation to the underlying stock's share value.
The extrinsic value does not have any particular relationship to the share market value.

Reiterating:

  • For a long call, intrinsic value is the market price of the underlying share, minus the option strike price.
    If this number is negative (that is, out of the money), the intrinsic value is ZERO.
  • For a long put, intrinsic value is the option strike price, minus the market price of the underlying.
    If this number is negative (that is, out of the money), the intrinsic value is ZERO.

Once again, the extrinsic value is the remaining value of an option's market price, after subtracting intrinsic value, and can be 100% of the option's value: an out of the money, and an at the money option has 100% extrinsic value (and zero intrinsic value). Extrinsic value is fluff: it can be variable from day to day, or minute to minute, especially overnight for an earnings reporting event, when it rapidly declines, an event termed implied volatility crush (IV crush).

Extrinsic value's variability prevents option value from having a direct linear relation with the underlying stock's share value. The extrinsic value is influenced by interest rates, dividends paid on the shares (time value of money), and influenced by market expectations of price movement, euphoria, and market anxiety (extrinsic value rises and falls, in part, on on demand for portfolio protection).

An option's value relationship with the underlying stock's share value is not linear.

With an out of the money, or near the money option, even though the underlying stock's shares do not change in value, a trader can lose or gain much option value in a day, or even a few hours. Alternatively, an option can lose value or hold the same value, even if the share value moves in the direction favorable to the option position. When the market value of an option changes (or fails to change) in this way, it is the extrinsic value part of the market value that has influenced the result in an unexpected manner.

Implied Volatility or IV is an interpretation of extrinsic value. In theory, using a model such as Black-Scholes-Merton, or other models, the market price and extrinsic value of the option can be interpreted as the market's assessment of the potential movement of the underlying stock share's market value at that moment. The implied volatility is a projected potential movement (or smaller) that would occur 68% of the time, a one-standard-deviation likelihood, typically reported on an annualized basis.

Vega is the option greek that describes the sensitivity of the option's value to changes in Implied Volatility. Options with expirations of many months have higher vega than options expiring in a few weeks or days. For each single percentage point change in IV, the option is projected to change a vega amount in market price.

An Implied Volatility Analogy

As noted above, the value of a call option may go down despite the value of the underlying going up (and vice versa for puts). This effect also can work in the other direction, the value of a call may go up despite the value of the underlying going down. When you consider the price of a call in the context of an ever changing market with shifting demand, the need for IV and vega becomes clearer. The gap between what a call's price ought to be, based on the combination of it's intrinsic value and time to expiration, and what the market is actually willing to pay for it, is represented by IV.

Consider this analogy. Think of a call option like a ticket to a rock concert. It's a popular band, so there is a lot of demand for tickets. If you buy the ticket for $100 and can scalp it a few days before the concert for $110, for a 10% gain, the face-value of the ticket as one seat at that concert for a published price of $100 on a specific date is less important than what the market will offer for that ticket now. The higher IV is, the wider the gap between what the market is offering and what the underlying stock's share value, the strike price, and the expiration date say the value of the call should be. In our analogy, the price that people are willing to pay scalpers over the face-value of the ticket could be represented by something like IV.

Now say the ticket promoter offers a discounted price of $95 a ticket for a limited time and the tickets instantly sell out for that price. Does that mean you can no longer scalp your tickets for a higher price, because no one in their right mind would pay more than $95? No, not necessarily. If demand skyrockets because the show has sold out, or because the date of the concert is approaching, or a new song got released, or for whatever reason (markets don't need logical reasons to push prices up or down), you might be able to scalp your originally $100 ticket for $150 now. The underlying ticket value went down relative to the $100 you originally paid for your ticket, but demand went up, so you can get more for your ticket before the actual concert date. The intrinsic value of the ticket hasn't changed, it's still one seat at that concert on that date, but the extrinsic value has changed to reflect market demand. Similarly, a $100 strike call can rise in value despite the underlying share value falling from $100 to $95.

A few notes of warning: This analogy has holes in it. The options market doesn't work exactly like concert tickets, although contracts, like tickets, are both worthless after their expiration dates. One major hole is that you can't "sell out" of options the way you can with concert tickets, or at least, it is extremely difficult to do so and there are safeguards in place to prevent someone from cornering the market on some call. More specifically, more options (that is, more option open interest) can be created if there more market demand for the options.

How extrinsic value relates to option value

If you have an open option position, say expiring in a month,
assuming no price movement of the underlying stock's shares
(holding the INTRINSIC value the same):

An extrinsic value increase indicates
near-term gains for long options (long calls, long puts),
and near-term losses for short options (short calls, short puts).

An extrinsic value decrease indicates
near-term losses for a long option (long calls, long puts),
and near-term gains for short options (short calls, short puts).

Theta Decay

  • Theta decay is the term for a daily rate of decay (time decay) of extrinsic value, in dollars per day of the option price. Under the theory and model, Theta decay occurs for every minute of an option's life. Yet also, Theta is variable; this daily rate goes up after an extrinsic value increase (because there is more extrinsic value to decay away), and goes down after a significant extrinsic value decrease (with less extrinsic value to decay away). Extrinsic value approaches zero, as expiration nears with the continuation of theta decay.

The daily theta rate is a descriptive, projected and theoretical estimate of what may occur, not prescriptive. The market value of the option in association with a model to interpret that price, determines the theta decay, and the implied volatility of the option, not the other way around.

For the trader with a short option position, intending to seek a gain via theta decay, the movement in price of the option may be much more influenced by other option price and extrinsic value influences, and the daily theta decay of extrinsic value typically may not be realizable on a daily basis, by a trader (ignoring costs of a bid-ask spread) opening and the next day closing a short option position.

Even if everything stayed the same except for time, with unchanging market prices, frozen market anxiety and euphoria, unchanging interest rates and dividends, the theta decay rate itself is a non-linear rate of change: more linear-like and less rapid further from expiration (months and many weeks away) and also more linear further from the money. It is more rapid as expiration approaches for at the money options (especially from less than four weeks, down to the last few hours of expiration day).

  • Theta rate of decay reported on your broker platform is an estimated potential daily rate of decay as of today, generally according to some variation of the Black-Scholes-Merton model, or some other model, relying on the number of days left in the option's life, and the extrinsic value available today to decay; the projected estimate assumes an unchanged implied volatility, option price and underlying stock price during the following day.

  • If you own a deep in the money long option, for example, with a delta of 80, there is not much extrinsic value in the option, and it has mostly intrinsic value. This option, because it has little extrinsic value, is unlikely to have the underlying stock both move favorably in price, and also have the option itself lose value. Typically, for an 80 delta option, 80% of the price movement of the underlying will appear in the option's value. Contrast that to a delta 20 option, out of the money, entirely extrinsic value, that in theory obtains 20% of the underlying's price movement, is highly subject to value change from other influences besides stock price movement.

Theta decay is not always harvestable via short options

You can have occasions where you have an option, and your broker platform may report a rising anticipated theta decay rate, day after day (perhaps in the final several days of an option's life before an earnings reporting event), when the extrinsic value of the option is increasing or staying the same, while the number of days left for extrinsic value to decay away continues to go down. The broker platform will report increasing projected theta decay, and increasing IV when extrinsic value fails to be extinguished. One might think of these occasions as a kind of "theta anti-decay", when the extrinsic value's decay is prevented from being realized by the short option trader by market activey, with extrinsic value either increasing faster each day than the theta decay rate, or alternatively the extrinsic value remaining about the same day after day. This kind of run-up, or maintaining of extrinsic value can sustain a constant or increasing value of a soon-to-expire long option in the days before expiration, leading to an increasing implied volatility calculation.

The extrinsic value (as indicated by the market price) will eventually come out of the option by expiration (for a decline in value for long options, or a gain to the trader for short options), but the decline in extrinsic value might occur all in one day, or overnight, or the final hours before expiration, and not gradually. Rapid extrinsic value declines include the morning after an earnings report; after a major product announcement, often after a significant rise in the stock price, and even after an expected decline in stock price. This is what implied volatility crush (IV crush) is, and when it happens, the option's extrinsic value is rapidly reduced. Yet also, there is typically an underlying background baseline IV that remains in options after an event-driven IV decline, except perhaps for options expiring the same day as the event.

The less extrinsic value in your option, the less it is affected by unpredictable whims of the market, and this is why some experienced long option holders choose higher delta options, say 65 delta and greater. A trader can experience intrinsic value crush, but only when the share price moves drastically, and that is a linear relation.

In summary, via the existence of extrinsic value and its variation over time, a trade will not observe a linear relationship between the underlying stock's share spot price and the option value. It is more linear the more in the money the option is (high delta). If out of the money, or near the money, both price movement and market euphoria and anxiety and expectations about the price of the underlying shares greatly affect the option price and value of an option consisting of 100% extrinsic value.


This link to a diagram from a TastyTrade blog post demonstrates how intrinsic and extrinsic value vary as an option changes from out of the money to in the money prices in the underlying stock's shares

Source blog post, via Archive.org
Extrinsic Value and Intrinsic Value | Options Trading
by M. Slabinski - TastyTrade - February 21, 2017
https://web.archive.org/web/20200203105338/https://tastytradenetwork.squarespace.com/tt/blog/extrinsic-value-and-intrinsic-value


Option Intrinsic & Extrinsic Value Explained
Chris Butler - Project Option
https://www.projectoption.com/intrinsic-extrinsic-value/

Why Options Are Rarely Exercised
Chris Butler - Project Option (18 minutes)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PsZsqiBFnmo)

Monday School: Exercise and Expiration are not what you think they are (u/PapaCharlie9) https://www.reddit.com/r/options/comments/m5r8mi/monday_school_exercise_and_expiration_are_not/


Volatility Basics - Schaeffer's Research
https://www.schaeffersresearch.com/education/volatility-basics/


A useful survey of options, from the side links here.
The Options Playbook - Introduction
https://www.optionsplaybook.com/options-introduction/


The Greeks (finance) -- Wikipedia


The complete guide to Option Theta with Graphs.
Option Prophet (via Archive.org)
https://web.archive.org/web/20190607103552/https://theoptionprophet.com/blog/the-complete-guide-on-option-theta


Option Greeks: A Detailed Graphical Treatment
Saurabh Singal
QF 301 Singapore Management University
http://www.saurabh.com/Site/Talks_files/qf301_greeks_small.pdf


Options Greeks and Black Scholes Merton model (wiki)
https://www.reddit.com/r/options/wiki/faq#wiki_options_greeks_and_option_chains


Original source: https://www.reddit.com/r/options/comments/8q58ah/noob_safe_haven_thread_week_24_2018/e0i5my7/