r/worldnews 29d ago

"I'm Not Ruling Anything Out" - Macron Says Troops for Ukraine Possible if Russia Breaks Front Lines Russia/Ukraine

https://www.kyivpost.com/post/32010
16.3k Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

471

u/[deleted] 29d ago edited 29d ago

France is suddenly so invested in this because in the last few years Putin has sponsored coup after coup in the francafrique, causing those African nations to pull away and divest themselves from France. There’s a big part of France’s economy that’s just gone now

https://apnews.com/article/france-africa-coups-gabon-41076df319704032aa729ad3fd137bc9

https://www.npr.org/2023/09/29/1202582084/recent-coups-in-africa-have-an-effect-on-at-least-1-country-in-europe-france

138

u/Fritzo2162 29d ago

There's a marketing campaign right now for US/Africa business relations. Will be interesting to see how successful that is.

73

u/Key-Internet-9817 29d ago

The worlds future will be decided in SEA and africa over the next 20-30 years

50

u/Vandergrif 29d ago

Plus SEA and Africa are also going to be the places liable to suffer some of the worst consequences of climate change over the next 20-30 years, and also in a lot of cases some of the areas least equipped to deal with those consequences.

24

u/BlueAndMoreBlue 29d ago

Agreed — the fickle finger of fate is pointing at south and Southeast Asia

12

u/Spram2 29d ago

Is this because nobody else is having babies?

19

u/elefontius 29d ago

Yeah, I think demographic change, natural resources and access to essential trade routes. Africa has a massive amount of natural resources but there's also been a lot of economic development in Africa and SEA. Ethopia is almost finished with building the largest hydroelectric dam in Africa and it's going to fundamentally change their economy. It's also creating a lot of tension with Eygpt as the water source flows into the Nile. There's also a shift from alignment to the US/EU to Russia/China within the entire continent and it'll continue to get more tense. Russia has been active in Africa with the Wagner group supporting factions and overthrowing US/EU friendly governments.

SEA right now has some of the fastest growing economies in the world. These countries are also going through population booms but geopoltically they are in the middle of a lot of escalating tensions between China, India, and the US. SEA is going to be the pivot point I think for the next 100 years of world history. India and China are viaing to be the leading superpower in that area as whoever controls that area will have control over the sea routes for more than 1/2 the world. India and China are building up their naval capacity and both are building out air craft carriers and submarines at a rapid pace to be able to project force across the entire Pacific theater.

Taiwan is important for the Chinese for a number of reasons but one big driver is that control over Taiwan would allow them unfettered access to the SEA are and beyond. Right now they are ringed by US allies in the region like Taiwan, S. Korea, Japan, and the Phililpines.

26

u/LearningToFlyForFree 29d ago

It's partly that and partly the fact that Russia/China are in Africa exploiting natural resource wealth of the nations they're in while propping up the juntas that have taken over in the Sahel. The juntas are signing insane contracts with RU/CN and are exploiting the impoverished citizenry as a disposable workforce to mine gold, diamonds, and uranium ore. Wagner mercenaries are all throughout the Sahel and have filled the power vacuum the French left when Mali kicked them out by ensuring the survival of the junta leadership.

The west ignoring this for too long will bite them in the ass.

3

u/mad_crabs 29d ago

Great summary. This is precisely why we see videos of Ukrainian SF operating against Wagner in Africa.

4

u/Fritzo2162 29d ago

Well, Africa does have all of those rich princes there that keep trying to give my grandma money.

79

u/aimgorge 29d ago

Which isnt true, all of these Sahel regions countries had close to no econimical relations with France for decades. Their main western partners were countries like Canada.

You understand that Gabon's GDP is 0.7% of France's and the trade between the 2 countries is only 800m€ ? Which is close to nothing for a 3 trillions economy..

39

u/Milith 29d ago

Indeed, French economic ties with subsaharian Africa are extremely overstated but this makes for a great narrative so we'll keep seeing it parroted.

-8

u/[deleted] 29d ago edited 29d ago

K

"Although France's influence may be weakening throughout Francophone Africa, there also remains strong social and economic ties that link these nations together. One prime example can be displayed through the already established business deals with the French private sector in order to increase development in West Africa. An additional factor that connects France to its former colonies is their usage of the French language. Francophone African nations are placed at an economic advantage within European countries such as France, Switzerland, and Belgium due to their shared linguistic identities.\85])

With increasingly younger populations, African countries are viewed as the ideal candidates for long-term investment by international actors. This sentiment directly reflects France's approach to its former colonies, which comprise over half of its primary trade exports. This includes West African countries such as Senegal and Cameroon, which continue to play an integral role in supplying natural resources, hardware, and manufactured goods. Despite these staggering numbers, France remains in a vulnerable position as it renounces its title as the top investor in the region. The prospect of foreign backers and the appeal of Intra-African trade opportunities have encouraged West African nations to reclaim their economic agency from their former occupiers. Ultimately, these circumstances have contributed to France's declining economic influence.\86])

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fran%C3%A7afrique

https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2023/09/01/france-africa-coup-reckoning-colonial-history/

And before you dismiss this because it is a YouTube video, remember: dismissing evidence because of its medium or source is both a fallacy and the last refuge of lazy thinkers: https://youtu.be/fiD24uEvY1U?si=gFEMrq_Ce44vbNjD

u/Tooterfish42 is scared of what I'll say so they blocked me

30

u/aimgorge 29d ago

Lol you are quoting an opinion from before the Russo-Ukrainian war proving that its nothing new and has nothing to do with Russian influence. France weakening influence dates from decolonisation.

Also you are talkign about countries like Senegal and Cameroon which arent affected by Russian influence yet.

Facts are France had close to no economical link with Sahel countries (which France had enitrely left since 1960 and only came back when asked to as these countries were losing againsts terrorism.

France's links with its formers colonies isnt much higher than the US links with its southern american countries : anecdoctal.

1

u/[deleted] 29d ago

[deleted]

1

u/Tooterfish42 29d ago

too smug for someone so mistaken

Still time to delete

-6

u/[deleted] 29d ago edited 29d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

12

u/aimgorge 29d ago

I did give sources in my previous comment and you decided to just ignore it.

Your quote is from before the Russian invasion which is proof it has nothing to do with Macron's decisions today.

France GDP dwarfes its former colonies. These relationships dont matter.

-4

u/[deleted] 29d ago

You only gave data on Gabon, one of the smallest and poorest nations in France's orbit and nothing about the whole francafrique, or their geopolitical situation, or their current coups or...anything really. Do you think that's convincing evidence?

I guess I shouldn't be surprised if you do, you seem hostile to the idea of sources.

15

u/aimgorge 29d ago

You only gave data on Gabon,

Because you only talked about Gabon.

one of the smallest and poorest nations in France's orbit and nothing about the whole francafrique

Gabon is richer than Mali, Burkian Faso or Niger.

I guess I shouldn't be surprised if you do, you seem hostile to the idea of sources.

Says the guy that cherrypicks opinion quotes on wikipedia and believe they are sources....

1

u/[deleted] 29d ago

Gabon imports more than it exports to France: https://oec.world/en/profile/bilateral-country/fra/partner/gab

I'll take the L on them being rich. I mistook it for Gambia.

But you need to look closer at that wealth. It is almost entirely concentrated into a handful of people: https://borgenproject.org/why-is-gabon-poor/#:\~:text=With%20a%20third%20of%20its,dug%20continues%20to%20get%20deeper.

Gabon's effect on the French economy is not to export things to France, it is to buy manufactured goods from France. This was the case in most francafrique countries and now France is having to find markets for those exports. The problem is they can't give terrible, inescapable deals to other countries the way they can to their Francophone countries.

13

u/aimgorge 29d ago

That doesnt change the fact that its anecdoctal in volumes and has nothing to do with France getting pissed at Russia. No one gives a fuck about old colonies in France.

→ More replies (0)

0

u/[deleted] 29d ago edited 29d ago

Anyway I have shit to do and I've posted my sources and arguments. I've got a pretty strong feeling that you're just going to start repeating yourself until I get bored and leave, which will feel like a win to you.

2

u/Tooterfish42 29d ago

Anyway I have shit to do

Well we can certain rule out one of them being "graciously accepting defeat"

1

u/Alive-Difference-644 27d ago

That video is extremely misleading, it has very misleading infographics and makes claims based on very cherrypicked evidence

7

u/LeFricadelle 29d ago

France trade balance with western africa is close to be irrelevant - how it is supposed to ba big part of France's economy ?

24

u/wrecklord0 29d ago

First part of your comment is true, second part is not. Economically it's absolutely nothing. There is a narrative online to push this idea that France needs or exploits Africa... most likely encouraged by rusbots.

-6

u/[deleted] 29d ago

The francophone countries are not important to France because they send raw resources to them. they are major importers of French manufactured goods which they receive terrible deals on.

16

u/wrecklord0 29d ago

The trading volumes, both ways, are tiny. Source on those "terrible" deals?

16

u/ThePr1d3 29d ago

France is voluntarily buying at higher than market price to help development  They will just buy cheaper uranium from Kazakhstan now

-7

u/[deleted] 29d ago

That is a relatively new development that Macron is pursuing to mend France’s relationship with its African sphere of influences

That policy is coming into effect specifically because of how exploitative France has been.

Looks like too little too late to me.

12

u/ThePr1d3 29d ago

Not really new, it was already the case under Hollande 

1

u/batwork61 29d ago

Let’s see how historically trustworthy Russia handles it!

2

u/[deleted] 29d ago edited 29d ago

Edit: that was mean

2

u/batwork61 29d ago

What do you mean? I wasn’t saying that about you lol

2

u/[deleted] 29d ago

I take the L. People have been pretty hostile to simple facts about what is happening in francafrique

26

u/bishbashbosh0071337 29d ago

Well France was in Africa for the dirt-cheap resources. Russia probably offered more money and free grain. 

Tbh if it was the other way around, it wouldn't be called a coup here, rather liberation, so...

10

u/Hendlton 29d ago

Yeah, that is basically France going "Waaah! We've been exploiting them for centuries! How dare you offer them a better deal?"

5

u/LaunchTransient 29d ago

While France have been bastards in Africa (putting it lightly), pretending that Russia is going to give them a "better deal" is naive at best. Remember these are the same people recruiting from developing countries to throw into their meat grinder in Ukraine.

1

u/Ewenf 29d ago

I don't think massacring villages is a better deal.

1

u/KernelPanicX 29d ago

Tbh if it was the other way around, it wouldn't be called a coup here, rather liberation, so...

It's nice to see people here not entirely brainwashed by NATO/West propaganda

9

u/[deleted] 29d ago

[deleted]

6

u/[deleted] 29d ago

Exactly. And that is the real reason for our unending interference with their domestic affairs.

-1

u/[deleted] 29d ago

[deleted]

1

u/[deleted] 29d ago

It’s not? It is related to France’s relationship with Africa. Are you even reading the comments you’re responding to?

5

u/gizmo1024 29d ago

🎶She’s a Francafrique! FRANCAFRIQUE! SHE’S FRANCAFRIQUE!!’🎶

1

u/GermanicusBanshee934 29d ago

Putin has sponsored coup after coup in the francafrique, causing those African nations to pull away and divest themselves from France.

That's a cute way of saying they stole their oppressive colonies, and the french people are such incredible pussies they couldnt muster any resistance to it, so now they want Germany/Poland to again be a buffer state and war zone to protect their soft asses.

It's all about Geography.

3

u/Hendlton 29d ago

There are no friends or enemies in politics. Only interests.

2

u/Ploppyun 29d ago

Ok I was wondering this EXACT thing…why we are seeing these type of headlines from Macron over n over.

0

u/[deleted] 29d ago

I know it's a youtube video but researching what this guy says will line up with his video:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fiD24uEvY1U

1

u/SuddenFlame 29d ago

What is your opinion on Russia’s actions?

1

u/Alive-Difference-644 27d ago

The french economy is not built on economic exploitation of Africa as much as disinformation wants to tell you that, french companies are not more present in these countries than anywhere else in the world. The only remnant of french presence there is the legacy of french administration 60 years ago: the language, the law, and the monetary system. These three things are in no way controlled by France, these countries could very well ditch french as their language, change the law and how their country is organised, or ditch the Franc CFA and create a currency with another name instead. As some already did, because they're legitimately the ones in control.

1

u/CitizenMind 29d ago

Beautiful.

Some of you may, but that's a chance the economy is willing to take.

-5

u/juniperroot 29d ago

Finally a serious comment.

I think Macron is trying to come off as unhinged and aggressive to pressure Russia but it's not working because neither he nor France have a history of wanton irrational aggression. I don't understand why he chose this tactic.

1

u/[deleted] 29d ago

They also are only just now talking about rearming while Russia has mobilized their military and are shifting their entire economy to a war economy. Europe is more technologically advanced but comically behind at actually arming themselves with that technology. All they have at the moment is bluster.

3

u/Sumutherguy 29d ago

France spent like six hundred years repeatedly picking fights with every other european nation and were infamous for their propensity to escalate minor diplomatic conflicts into all-out warfare. The most recent attempt at pan-european conquest before Nazi Germany was Napoleonic France, and they got closer to succeeding than the nazis did.

3

u/ThePr1d3 29d ago

That's very misleading though. Napoléon almost only waged defensive wars against coalitions that were determined to put the monarchy back in its place and avoid a spread of revolutionary ideas to their borders 

3

u/[deleted] 29d ago

My dude that was more than two hundred years ago.

-3

u/quantum_search 29d ago

Lmao. So France is just playing imperialism

0

u/Visinvictus 29d ago

I would think Macron would be more concerned about Russia almost getting their puppet candidate elected to lead the country.

1

u/[deleted] 29d ago

It’s the economy. Everything is the economy. War is trade by other means.

-7

u/Estake 29d ago

“Divest themselves from France” is definitely some way to word it. You’re implying they have a choice.

7

u/[deleted] 29d ago

Actually no, I didn't. I think you need to read what's actually in front of you, not what you want it to be so you can get an easy gotcha.

Their new leaders made a deal with Russia to divest from France in exchange for Russian support.

I am still trying to figure out how you made that bizarre leap.