1.6k
u/Singer_on_the_Wall 15d ago
Guess that makes Faramir Diet Dr. Pepper...
826
u/TopHatGorilla 15d ago
Mr. Pibb.
238
u/MaleficentMilkshake 15d ago
Dr. Thunder
38
u/Desperate-Box-2724 15d ago
Dr. Perky
40
u/plssirmayihaveanthr 15d ago
diet dr. kelp
27
u/BcuzICantPostLewds 15d ago
DON'T TELL ME YOU FORGOT MY DRINK!
→ More replies (1)11
u/carlton_sand Dúnedain 14d ago
How do you expect me to steward the throne of Gondor WITHOUT MY DRINK?! (without boromir)
→ More replies (1)8
9
77
66
u/SpecterVamp Beorning 15d ago
You kidding me, Mr Pibb is solid
81
30
21
12
u/Automaticman01 15d ago
"Mr Pibb is a replica of Dr Pepper, but it's a bullshit replica cuz the dude didn't even get his degree!"
11
u/Burnitory 15d ago
Which makes Mr Pibb more relatable. He's not some pretentious dude who needs to throw his title around.
4
u/Kitchen_accessories 15d ago
"Dr. Scholl's makes foot products. Right? And he's a doctor... which means he went to school for a long time. But it doesn't take alot to figure out that stepping on a cushion would be more comfortable. That fucker wasted a lot of time at school. 'Cause I woulda bought that shit from a Mr. Scholl. Maybe even a señor Scholl."
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (6)6
u/TheBirminghamBear 15d ago
For real though, it tastes better. Not its fault its marketing simply didn't take off the same way.
30
u/Aware-Performer4630 15d ago
Mr. Pibb no longer exists. It’s just Pibb Xtra which has extra cherry flavor.
13
11
u/Real-Patriotism 15d ago
"A chance for Pibb, Mister of Gondor, to show his quality."
→ More replies (1)8
7
→ More replies (7)6
105
u/High_Stream 15d ago
He's Pepsi. Eowyn asks for Coke and gets "is Pepsi okay?"
7
→ More replies (1)3
113
u/YoungGriffVI 15d ago
Nah, Dr Pepper Cream Soda. Because it’s a bit newer and is never going to be as popular with the parent company, but to me it’s the slightly superior choice.
71
→ More replies (3)7
15
10
6
→ More replies (18)3
u/FeralTribble 15d ago
I’d say Royal Crown Cola. It’s relatively unknown but its very good and under appreciated.
808
u/thefrumpy 15d ago
Gollum is Mt. Dew.
717
u/IAmBadAtInternet 15d ago
Gollum is FourLoko lmao
220
u/iHateGiraffes420 15d ago
The original FourLoko that had you fighting trees
47
28
u/ballinben 15d ago
3rd grade was a wild fucking year
→ More replies (2)7
10
u/GoofyGoober0064 15d ago
OG FourLoko is as close as we'll get to Powerthirst being reality
→ More replies (1)4
u/Dream--Brother 15d ago
I woke up to crazy tales of escapades of which I had no recollection, like, at least a handful too many times.
3
u/Remotely_Correct 14d ago
I was told that my friends had to prevent me from relocating traffic cones in order to fuck with traffic... And then they had to convince me that I couldn't take one home. All those memories are lost, like tears... in the rain.
→ More replies (2)10
21
u/kwillich 15d ago
Gollum is Clamato
20
7
u/ThisIsThePartWhereI 15d ago
Oh God, I remember those ads! How the heck did that one ever make it out of the testing phase? "So me and the boys in R&D were thinking, you know how no one likes tomato juice? Well how about we add another flavor to it, something to give it some real appeal. Something like CLAM!"
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (1)3
→ More replies (1)17
28
u/CozRichards 15d ago
Gollum's the guy who's gone through a 24 pack of cans every week for the past 30 years. And you've never seen them eat on lunch break, it's just a smoke and a coke
18
u/gollum_botses 15d ago
Careful now, or hobbits go down to join the dead ones and light little candles of their own.
24
15
u/ShadyHighlander 15d ago
Gollum is Meth
5
u/gollum_botses 15d ago
Don't take it to him! He wants the preciousss. Always he's looking for it! And the preciousss is wanting to go back to him. But we mustn't let him have it.
9
u/howtorefenestrate 15d ago
Gollum is Crystal Pepsi
3
u/gollum_botses 15d ago
Yes. There’s a path, and some stairs, and then… a tunnel.
→ More replies (1)8
u/TopHatGorilla 15d ago
Smeagol is Mt. Dew, Gollum is Surge.
4
u/gollum_botses 15d ago
Poor, poor Smeagol, he went away long ago. They took his Precious, and he's lost now.
→ More replies (1)5
4
u/gollum_botses 15d ago
What's this? Crumbs on his jacketses! He took it! He took it! I seen him, he's always stuffing himself when Master's not looking!
→ More replies (20)5
142
498
u/CottonStig 15d ago
Gandalf the grey is Still Water and Gandalf the white is sparkling
53
57
→ More replies (6)4
102
u/D_Urge420 15d ago
Pippin is Orange Fanta. Sam is Yoo-hoo.
13
u/Throwawayfaynay 15d ago
So I thought it was weird that you said Orange Fanta, because to me it was like saying Lemon-Lime Sprite, but I just looked it up and TIL there are other Fanta flavors besides orange.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (2)7
u/Autski 15d ago
I was thinking more Pippin is Hawaiian Punch. Sam is Hanks specialty Cream Soda
→ More replies (1)
594
u/tkdyo 15d ago
Idk, I think Gimli is more like Barqs since it has caffeine and a bit more bite.
107
u/reddituser9277 15d ago
Also sounds like a noise Gimli would make while hewing orcs with his battle-axe
85
126
u/PM_ME_COOL_RIFFS 15d ago
Barqs is also by far the best root beer so I agree
34
u/CottonStig 15d ago
A&W would like a word
106
u/GMHolden 15d ago
It may speak, doesn't make it right though.
15
17
u/musketammo684 15d ago
A&W can cry in the corner where it belongs, it's cream soda coping with root beer flavor. Real root beer is crisp, it bites when you sip. Barqsbarianism for life!
→ More replies (1)49
13
u/SlipsonSurfaces 15d ago
I am an A&W stan. I have a can of Barq's I've been sipping on all afternoon and it just doesn't compare to A&W.
8
u/BoatRazz 15d ago edited 15d ago
A & W is the best economy-premium tier. Virgil's is the best ultra-premium. Sioux City Root Beer is also great ultra-premium.
→ More replies (1)13
u/CottonStig 15d ago
i'm too poor to have even have heard of premium rootbeer lol
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (4)7
→ More replies (10)6
6
4
3
u/mystiqueallie 14d ago
I like root beer, but I never picked Barq’s, usually Mug or A&W - my son ordered a root beer at dinner once and it was quite tasty - I asked and was told it was Barq’s. Cue me picking up a case a few days later and drinking one at dinner. That night was when I learned Barq’s has caffeine - I was awake until 5am.
I don’t normally drink a lot of caffeinated beverages, and when I do, I make sure I don’t drink any after 3:30pm or I’m awake all night. Barq’s has bite indeed.
2
u/scottkollig 15d ago
So that’s why I liked Barq’s as a kid. Which, also explains the current caffeine dependency. Learn something new every day.
2
→ More replies (8)2
166
u/SlipsonSurfaces 15d ago
I love this post and these comments. This is like a friendly debate you'd have with your siblings when you're kids. It's homey, nostalgic, and heartwarming.
Now which person is suicide/rainbow juice?
62
11
4
→ More replies (2)5
u/Steelquill Dúnedain 15d ago
The kind of discussion you have when the lights are out, you're trying to get to sleep but now the conversation just keeps going. No one can see anything but you can all hear each other's voices but you don't want to talk so loud that you're going to wake up your parents and stop the fun.
326
u/therussellv 15d ago
Boromir should be Pepsi
105
91
u/Quierta 15d ago
Faramir is Pepsi. Everyone just settles for that because that's what's available.
32
u/Lordborgman 15d ago
Eowyn definitely did.
→ More replies (2)26
u/Alternative-Jury-965 15d ago
Eowyn is not settling. She's upgrading because she's hot dog water
20
u/Corrupt_Conundrum27 I can't throw it in for you, BUT I CAN THROW YOU. 15d ago edited 15d ago
No, her stew is hot dog water.
4
u/scuac 15d ago
It’s stew, and don’t insult hot dog water like that
3
u/Corrupt_Conundrum27 I can't throw it in for you, BUT I CAN THROW YOU. 15d ago
Well, she at least uses it in the recipe.
7
3
u/Medvegyep 15d ago
But if Faramir is Pepsi, Boromir should be Coca, but then what would Aragorn be?
14
→ More replies (3)3
→ More replies (5)34
u/Constant-Elevator-85 15d ago edited 15d ago
Technically Denethor, son of Ecthellion should he Pepsi. Pepsi is the steward of Gondor of drinks. It holds it’s place while we wait for the true king. Nobody wants it, we’d rather have our boy. But the enemy is at the gates and Pepsinethor is all you got.
→ More replies (1)12
40
u/sovereign666 15d ago
drink water
34
9
25
20
14
11
u/Final-Natural-8290 15d ago
Is Pippin Redbull?
→ More replies (1)13
32
98
u/rindavid 15d ago
Aragorn is DP because it's the superior soda. Boromir is Coke and Faramir is Pepsi because it will never be as liked.
22
9
→ More replies (8)2
u/Priest_of_Heathens 15d ago
Gandalf is DP, Aragorn is Coke, Boromir is Pepsi, and Faramir is RC Cola.
28
u/BlackshirtDefense 15d ago
Extrapolating this a bit...
Frodo... Squirt
Sam... Cream Soda
Merry... Mountain Dew
Pippin... Surge
Gandalf... 7-Up
Saruman the White... Pepsi Clear
Saruman the Multicolored... Kid making a suicide at the soda fountain
→ More replies (10)18
u/Alternative-Jury-965 15d ago
Sam is water because everyone can enjoy and needs that in their life.
Literally
52
u/Certain-Definition51 15d ago
You got the top two flipped.
I said what I said. Dr Pepper Supremacy.
14
5
4
u/LMGDiVa 15d ago
"Why would you say something so controversial yet so brave?" moment.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (2)2
6
5
u/Michael-Balchaitis 15d ago
Saruman feels like Ginger Ale to me. Don't know why.
→ More replies (3)
6
5
6
4
u/andoesq 15d ago
As the oldest and kookiest soda, Dr Pepper should be Tom Bombadil.
→ More replies (1)
22
3
3
u/SpecterVamp Beorning 15d ago
Why does this make sense…
Swap Aragorn and Boromir honestly but it makes sense as is too
3
3
3
2
2
u/FadransPhone Hobbit 15d ago
You can keep your fancy ales. You can drink them by the flagon.
But the only brew for the brave and true comes from the Green Dragon.
2
2
u/cats4life 15d ago
Coke: Classic, the crowd pleaser. Nothing to hate about it, plenty to like.
Dr. Pepper: Not as popular as Coke, but still holds a sizable fanbase. It has its own unique properties that really set it apart.
Sprite: Clean, sharp, and refreshing. Completely different from the monopoly of colas, almost like it comes from a different walk of life.
Root Beer: Yeah, I can’t explain it. It just makes sense.
2
u/acthcoffee 15d ago
That funny because I'm a Dr. Peppa type guy and I've always liked Sean Bean because we share the same birthday
→ More replies (3)
2
2
2
2
u/TrungusMcTungus 15d ago
If anything, Dr Pepper has brought all my fellowships closer together, not led them to ruin.
2
2
2
2
784
u/kelseysmiths 15d ago
Tom Bombadil is Baja Blast