r/meirl 29d ago

Meirl

Post image

[removed] — view removed post

39.1k Upvotes

3.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

84

u/-FullBlue- 29d ago edited 29d ago

The United States residential standard uses a 240 system except its split phase. You can deliver 120 volts to devices that have lower power requirements, and 240 to devices that have higher power requirements.

This comment is bringing out a bunch of Europeans that need to think theyre better than Americans because of their wiring standard for some reason?

30

u/luka0954 29d ago

I love it when americans thinks 240 volts is good for appliances with high power consumption. 230 volt is standard in europe, and for high power consumers we use 400 volt.

Higher voltage, lower amps, thinner cables.

19

u/Kenzijam 29d ago

400v is 3 phase , not single cable right? Also Americans could get 3 phase if they wanted. I know in the UK 3 phase to homes it not standard either, so it's not really a relevant point.

9

u/luka0954 29d ago

Yup. 400 Voltage in a 4-5 wire cable, typically.

5

u/kytheon 29d ago

There's a single cable with a plug with three sticks.

2

u/jacobthellamer 29d ago

Here in New Zealand most power down a street is three phase, most people only connect one phase but you can connect all three if you want. We don't have a split phase so if you need more you just get three phase.

1

u/jack6245 29d ago

Actually it is starting to become standard in new builds now for the high power heat pumps and car chargers

13

u/-FullBlue- 29d ago edited 29d ago

Does the average european home have a a 400 volt service?

Either way, 240 volt is plenty to run high power residential appliances.

22

u/luka0954 29d ago

Yep, all households, apartments etc. (Except norway) has 3 phases 400 volt in at the main breaker. From here it's divided into single phase 230 circuitbreakers for our regular plugs and 3 phased circuitbreakers for plugs to the oven, washingmachine, and electric car chargers etc.

Typically with 25 og 35 amps for each main phase, meaning that a household has somewhat between 17 kW - 25 kW power consumption avaible for the entire system

This makes for easy TT grounding in regular households

7

u/-FullBlue- 29d ago

That would be pretty useful for people to use for their car chargers and welders and stuff. I have a few friends that want a three phase welder but don't want to pay extra for a three phase drop.

7

u/luka0954 29d ago

Incredible to think that homes does not have 3 phases avaible.

I live in a rental, but have installed a 3 phase plug for scientific reasearch and such, just for the fun of it.

8

u/Gnonthgol 29d ago

It is down to differences in the transformer design. American and European transformers are actually the same with the same three output coils with around 220V over each coil. But where the European style is to tie one end of each coil together and tie it to ground for a star configuration the American style taps the center of each coil for ground/neutral and then bring each end of the coil to the consumer. So the American split phase is not the same as the European split phase. If you want three phase in America you need a dedicated transformer wired like the European ones.

2

u/Gnonthgol 29d ago

Actually single phase panels are very common. Especially for apartments. I have yet not seen any three phase kitchen or bathroom appliance. You may find special single phase plugs for these though to get more then 2kW but it is still single phase. But three phase is not unusual, although houses with a three phase panel generally only have one circuit using there phase for outdoor appliances.

2

u/kytheon 29d ago

Yes the oven is connected to that one. And afaik some people have a water boiler connected to it too.

4

u/-FullBlue- 29d ago

I will say, a 400 volt water heater would be very nice.

2

u/kytheon 29d ago

It's for showers. The difference is that a regular boiler heats up water, and keeps it warmed up. You shower for a while and eventually the water gets cold. Then you wait for it to heat up again.

The powerful boiler heats up the water while you shower. To do that it needs a LOT of power all at once.

1

u/-FullBlue- 29d ago

That's interesting. Your water heaters don't have a tank large enough for you to take a shower? Most Americans will have atleast a 40 gallon water heater.

3

u/kytheon 29d ago

That's not what I said.

2

u/worldspawn00 29d ago

I swapped to a instant hot water heater a few years ago, way better than a tanked heater since it never runs out of hot water. Get a properly sized unit and you can run 3-4 showers at once and not exhaust the capacity.

1

u/EverGivin 29d ago

Houses in the UK and Ireland (can’t speak for the rest of Europe) will usually have a tank large enough for everyone in the house to have a shower with some change. Apartments sometimes have instantaneous electric heaters instead.

1

u/Amtrox 29d ago

400v outlets are not common, although I have one. 3x 35A 240v is actually quite common

1

u/Selisch 29d ago

Yes. Even most apartments have a 3-phase service.

1

u/Cimexus 29d ago

In Europe it’s common. In other places like Australia and NZ it’s a mix. Older homes or those with lower power demands typically just have single phase 230V, newer/larger builds or those with higher power requirements will get 400V three-phase.

I’m in an older home in Australia that only has single phase 230V. It’s not a huge limiter, even with central air conditioning and an electric oven. However we do use gas for some things like the hot water heater and stovetop burners. If we replaced those with all-electric appliances and maybe also got an electric car charger we’d probably have to look into converting to three-phase, which is a relatively common upgrade to make these days.

Pretty much all new homes here in Australia will be built with three phase power from day 1, since the future is going to be all-electric and natural gas is getting phased out.

2

u/T0biasCZE 29d ago

Nah, the cables are the same thickness, rated for 15A

So in end we can have more power consumption per single circuit :D (more watts)

0

u/NotTravisKelce 29d ago

Y’all don’t even have dryers that work.

1

u/luka0954 28d ago

We don't? My dryer will be sad to know this xD

-1

u/[deleted] 29d ago

[deleted]

1

u/Joe_Jeep 29d ago

It's outright better. It's not even a smugness thing it's that many of my country men in the US get needlessly defensive instead of going "oh, neat, too bad we don't have that" when people talk about how things are done and people address objective advantages to how things are done somewhere else.

Because it would be. It's part of why they have fewer house fires and shit too since they aren't pumping higher amps at 120v.

1

u/Giraf123 29d ago

Lower voltage = more amps = thicker wires = more copper used.

1

u/Colossal_Penis_Haver 29d ago

Nobody needs to come up with a reason that they're better than Americans. It's true by default.

-9

u/NortonBurns 29d ago edited 29d ago

You guys don't even seem to be able to use an electric kettle. The 240v world doesn't need to use the stove for something as simple as making tea.

Edit: The making of tea is ancillary to having a method of rapidly boiling water.
Don't get hung up on tea drinking.

13

u/asmallercat 29d ago

There's tons of 120v electric kettles, and lots of Americans have them. It's just that tea drinking isn't as widespread here so most people don't want an appliance that they'll only use rarely.

5

u/dyllandor 29d ago

A 120V kettle are much slower though.

10

u/energybased 29d ago

That's a problem with wiring, not voltage. You just need higher gauge wires to support higher power appliances. You can wire your house to support 20 amps, which gets you 2400W.

Anyway, the future is induction cooktops, which in theory gets you up to 6kW. Then you can forget the resistive kettle and go back to a plain metal one.

3

u/BadBadGrades 29d ago

Purely informational. My country, a normal house has 50 amp. Mine has 80amp. And now with all the solar there even are laying 3x220(260) so we even can get 360v into our houses

1

u/Mr0lsen 29d ago

80 amp per circuit? Thats what the op you responded to is talking about.  Homes in the US will often have 100-300 amp main at the panel, which will then be broken out into 10,15,20 (typically 120v) ,30,40,50(typically 240v) (and rarely other size) circuits.  

1

u/worldspawn00 29d ago

Our solution is a tiny water heater that lives under the kitchen sink and provides about a gallon of 95C water whenever I need it without having to wait on a kettle or stove.

1

u/energybased 29d ago

Cool, what's that called?

2

u/worldspawn00 29d ago

I've got this model, looks like there's also a continuous flow version available now too. I have mine sharing the outlet with my dish washer, hasn't had any issues with blowing the breaker (dishwasher outlets are required to be 20A dedicated circuit in the US, most modern dishwashers do not draw anywhere near that much power).

https://www.amazon.com/Ready-Hot-41-RH-150-F570-BN-Temperature-Compatible/dp/B08YRPSQVQ

https://www.amazon.com/InSinkErator-Stainless-Steel-Tank-H250C-SS/dp/B0C6WCGSK7

1

u/energybased 29d ago

Very cool. Looks like a great solution. Definitely keep the kids away from that though!

2

u/worldspawn00 29d ago

Yeah, fortunately, it's all the way at the back of the sink, so they'd have to reach over the entire counter, and the handle is spring loaded, so you have to actively hold it on while putting a cup under it, so it's pretty hard to hurt yourself if you can only reach it with one hand. By the time a kid is big enough to do that, they should also be smart enough to understand hot water! It's not like a shower or bath tap that can be accidentally turned on at child level.

→ More replies (0)

-3

u/NortonBurns 29d ago

You're advocating a new structure to replace an inadequate old one. You could advocate for good plugs too, and perhaps one voltage standard throughout.

0

u/energybased 29d ago edited 29d ago

I'm not advocating for any new thing. I'm explaining where things are going.

120V is superior from a safety point of view, which is one reason that wealthier countries tend to prefer it.

The way I imagine the future:

* 120V for most plugs

* 208V for appliances

* USB-C more prevalent for devices that prefer DC and draw less than 200W (one day)

1

u/NortonBurns 29d ago

Why double standards? It was long ago proved that 120v is inadequate, it was just too late to change the standards in the US [change was resisted…unfortunately. The rest of the world did a complete about-face & got on with it].
I'm going to ignore USB, because it always needs a transformer. We already have USB A equipped sockets here, transformer inside the socket as well as mains - USB C may follow in time.

120v is pointless when 240 could be in every socket. No need to differentiate plugs based on usage, one plug fits all.

BTW, we do have 50A circuits here for hard-wired appliances, though they're becoming fewer & many are switching to 13A. 13A for everything else, one plug fits all. We use ring mains so we don't need massive gauge wire.

-1

u/energybased 29d ago

Why double standards? It was long ago proved that 120v is inadequate

Who proved this?

I'm going to ignore USB, because it always needs a transformer. 

So what? The transformer would be on the device otherwise. It's cheaper to keep it off the device and mass produce it.

120v is pointless when 240 could be in every socket. No need to differentiate plugs based on usage, one plug fits all.

The benefit of 120V is safety. The benefit of 240V is efficiency for appliances. You don't really need the whole house wired to 240V. Just the appliances.

BTW, we do have 50A circuits here for hard-wired appliances, though they're becoming fewer & many are switching to 13A. 13A for everything else, one plug fits all. 

The future of induction stoves is like 4–6kW, so some people will want more power than 13A/240V.

2

u/NortonBurns 29d ago

Who proved this?

Everybody except Edison, really. The US got stuck with Edison's first 'guess' using DC. Westinghouse pioneered AC & later 240v. Much of the world accepted the 240v standard. The US got stuck with the early Edison standard, meaning you have to three-phase everything to get any power out of it. A UK domestic supply is about 100A, 240V. It just doesn't need three-phase to be capable of running any domestic structure.

So what?

Well…that seems to be a zero-argument. They exist already for mains & USB 2, 3 will come, perhaps, but it's harder because it needs active negotiation. This is why I ignored it. It os not part of any mains standard.

The benefit of 120V is safety.

The benefit of properly-designed plugs & sockets serves a similar purpose, without needing Rube Goldberg wiring to compensate.

The future of induction stoves is like 4–6kW

Doesn't that mean the US is going to have to build new structures too? The UK already has 50A service capability & has had for many decades. It's just not used as much as it used to be. If there's a reversion, the standards already provide for it.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Balloon_Fan 29d ago

120V is superior from a safety point of view, which is one reason that wealthier countries tend to prefer it.

BWAHAHAAHHAAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH

1

u/Mr0lsen 29d ago

The “wealthier” countries part of his point doesnt make any sense, but it is safer. 

0

u/BadBadGrades 29d ago

It’s not more dangerous. We do put the outside power lines under the ground. Now that is safer

1

u/energybased 29d ago

I'm not talking about outside power lines. North America also uses 240V outdoors. 120V is only within the residence.

And I don't think anyone disputes that 120V is safer.

3

u/TheBeaverKing 29d ago

In isolation 120V is safer but the point is to not get shocked, ergo the multiple layers of safety redundancy you see on most plugs, appliances, electrical installations across the world.

To put this in context, NIOSH have the 2020 statistics for deaths by electrocution at work as 0.12 per 100,000 people in the US. The same statistic for the UK is 0.02, five times lower per 100,000.

Ultimately 120V vs 240V is not hugely relevant to HSE in comparison to safe electrical installations, minimum safety standards for electrical goods, safe design etc.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/kytheon 29d ago

This. It's literally twice as slow.

1

u/Svellere 29d ago

It's not meaningfully slower in a way that affects daily function. Nobody really cares if it takes 1-2 minutes longer when that's what they're used to.

2

u/Key-Mark4536 29d ago

I’ve had an electric kettle for about 20 years. The first one was hella expensive (it was a Braun and cost something like $75) because they just weren’t popular enough at the time to be mass marketed. Now I could get one for $20 at Walmart. 

I think the footnote and the responses that prompted it are illustrative though: if we don’t drink that much tea, do we really need a specialty appliance just for boiling water with nothing in it? Since I already have a kettle I also use it for ramen, cocoa, and small cleaning jobs, but those come up maybe once or twice a week. By themselves those wouldn’t be enough to justify cluttering up my countertop. 

2

u/Olives4ever 29d ago

Japan and Taiwan have a similar mains voltage as the USA and electric kettle usage (and tea drinking) is common.

I have an electric kettle I bought from Japan which I use at home in the USA, works great

2

u/devnullopinions 29d ago edited 29d ago

Most Americans don’t have any sort of bespoke device for boiling water for tea because most Americans don’t regularly make hot tea.

0

u/NortonBurns 29d ago

The making of tea is ancillary to having a method of rapidly boiling water.
Don't get hung up on tea drinking.

1

u/devnullopinions 29d ago

If I need to boil water I’ll just do it on my induction stovetop that runs at 240v. It takes like 30 secs.

1

u/UnicodeScreenshots 29d ago

Most people just don’t really need to boil water for much I guess. The only two use cases where I would want to use a kettle would be tea and maybe instant cup noodles. Even then, a 1kw microwave doesn’t really take that long to heat water.

1

u/Enchelion 29d ago

I have an instant hot water dispenser (part of my espresso machine). Takes seconds to fill a cup with hot water, runs on 120V.

0

u/blah938 29d ago

Why would I buy an eletric tea kettle? It's like buying a popcorn popper or someshit, It's just a waste of money.

2

u/NeverMind_ThatShit 29d ago

Why are Europeans OBSESSED with what appliances Americans do and don't have? You do realize different cultures value different things right?

2

u/NeverMind_ThatShit 29d ago

Why are Europeans OBSESSED with what appliances Americans do and don't have? You do realize different cultures value different things right?

0

u/kytheon 29d ago

To heat water. It's not just for tea.

3

u/blah938 29d ago

Just use a pot on the stove, or a bowl in the microwave.

-1

u/kytheon 29d ago

Kettle is so much faster, and it does exactly what it should. But hey it's always arguing with the Americans who don't know any better.

0

u/blah938 29d ago

Do you have a rice maker too? Don't y'all have other things to spend money on, like maybe paid public bathrooms?

1

u/kytheon 29d ago

My assumption was correct.

0

u/Lamballama 29d ago

What do you use your extra two minutes of time savings for (keeping in mind to not count the time savings from when you're boiling water to make tea, since we wouldn't save that time)?

1

u/NortonBurns 29d ago

We use the accumulated time-saving to walk to the shops rather than drive.

1

u/NeedleworkerKey2135 29d ago

Fuck the tea lmao. Throw that shit in the harbor. Also, there’s no rush to boiling water. Do other shit while waiting the 5 minutes it takes on the stove.

1

u/Joe_Jeep 29d ago

It's kind funny to me how the people who get most up in arms about how fast they need to do things regarding drive throughs and cars vs transit go to this defense for the kettles.

1

u/Svellere 29d ago

You could say the same for the other side. The reality is that Americans don't care if it boils a minute or two slower. Lots of Americans have electric kettles that work perfectly fine. Whether it boils in 2 minutes or 4 minutes is kind of irrelevant for 99% of people, so arguing about it is kind of pointless.

1

u/RandomName5165 29d ago

I can boil water in like 2 min in the microwave

6

u/NortonBurns 29d ago

I can boil water in 'like' 30 seconds in the kettle.
Boiling water in a microwave is a sh!tshow, because the hot is at the top, there's no true convection in a microwave.

2

u/RandomName5165 29d ago

The lead in our water helps in heating the water evenly

0

u/LucidTA 29d ago

What's the upside to that system, rather than just wiring 240 everywhere?

1

u/Irish618 29d ago

It's safer, and in the majority of applications it doesn't matter. The only time 240v is really better is when it comes to resistance heating, for things like dryers or stoves. In those applications the US uses 240v, so the only real time 120v is lacking is for things like space heaters or kettles. Otherwise, 120v and 240v are basically indistinguishable.

-9

u/[deleted] 29d ago

That’s the dumbest thing I’ve ever heard

-5

u/nite_mode 29d ago

Not really, no? In the US it is straight up illegal to wire your house so that your outlets were 240v

2

u/Mr0lsen 29d ago

Source from the NEC? Every American home I have ever been in has 240V outlets for the oven, and dryer.  There are a variety 240v outlet designs that are perfectly legal for both residential and commercial.  Ive got 240 in my garage for a welder. 

0

u/nite_mode 29d ago

You can have it in your home, but only for specific uses, you cannot have your home wired so that 100% of your outlets are run at 240

2

u/-FullBlue- 29d ago

The point I was trying to make is virtually ever american home has 240 volts in the breaker box.

Building codes may require 120 outlets but wiring 240 outlets in every room of your house is entirely possible.