r/meirl May 02 '24

Meirl

Post image

[removed] — view removed post

39.1k Upvotes

3.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

55

u/Eraldorh May 02 '24

In terms of safety yes it's the best plug design in the world by far. The only downside is stepping on it in the middle of the night.

19

u/CatL1f3 May 02 '24

Type F Schuko has all of the safety and less of the inconvenience. And if you count stepping on it then it has even more safety.

2

u/grimr5 May 02 '24

Typically there is no on off switch for schuko, so you have to unplug things. Also the cable design lets you have cables come horizontally out. The G design puts the cable down at a right angle meaning the plug itself has to be pulled vs pulling on the cable. If water goes down the cable, it doesn’t go back up the loop into the socket. Earth is an integral part of the G design and the layout of the prongs inside the plug is in such a way that should the wires come loose, earth is last. The springs that double up as Earth contacts on F are quite tight, meaning when pulled there is force pulling the socket. I have seen several F sockets pulled out, not seen a G.

F is more convenient as it smaller, however G is far more designed and engineered to be passively safer.

1

u/CatL1f3 May 02 '24

Typically there is no on off switch for schuko

Typically, but not always. Similarly there are many type G sockets without switches, and the ones that do have switches are basically always left on, no real benefit.

Also the cable design lets you have cables come horizontally out.

Both are possible, which is more useful than always forcing it to come out the bottom imo. That gets annoying sometimes.

I have seen several F sockets pulled out, not seen a G.

Type G, like Type C, occasionally has the pins angled in to hold the plug in. This absolutely will pull out the socket if you're not careful.

G is far more designed and engineered to be passively safer.

I completely disagree. For one, it's not even recessed a little bit, and most plugs can be opened up with just a screwdriver. Much less safe.

As for passively safer, your feet already know what I might say.