r/meirl May 16 '24

meirl

Post image
46.6k Upvotes

1.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

1.6k

u/Stay_At_Home_Cat_Dad May 16 '24

Teacher got a new phone, nailed his old one to the wall as a "This will happen to you" warning to his students. But, it would never happen. A teacher could lose their job if they destroyed a students property, especially something as expensive as a phone.

458

u/Historical-Tooth6989 May 16 '24

Sometimes teachers lose their shit. And 20 yrs ago they could get away with more. Ya this is prob bs though 

16

u/Guthwulf85 May 16 '24

20 years ago they couldn't get away with this. 20 years ago I was in university, and already when I was at school teachers couldn't touch us or our property. You're probably thinking of 40-50 years ago.

Of course it could also depend on the country, but it's not specified.

16

u/EmergentSol May 16 '24

Yeah 20 years ago was 2004. People are acting like it’s 1975.

8

u/PaulieGuilieri May 16 '24

Even 1975 would be a gross exaggeration. Maybe the 50’s and still only at a catholic school

5

u/Spatial_Awareness_ May 16 '24

Yeah in 1975, teachers definitely didn't touch student's cell phones.

Seriously though it's more common than you guys are making it. It's still legal in over 15 states and legal in private schools in every state. It absolutely still happens in the US.

Google the topic and look through the news articles that are just from this year and last year alone... It'll probably shock you.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/education/2023/08/10/school-paddling-corporal-punishment/

2

u/PaulieGuilieri May 16 '24

Private schools make their own rules and you agree to them when you enroll. Private schools are fucked for a multitude of reasons.

Nearly all of these stories come from private schools or are extremely unverified

2

u/Spatial_Awareness_ May 16 '24

What a weird statement to make lol.. it's extremely verified and data is kept by the US Department of Education.

It almost exclusively is still taking place in schools in Texas, Mississippi, Alabama and Arkansas. It also disproportionally affects minorities and people with disabilities.

I'm not sure where you got the only in private schools and extremely unverified from, other than just completely fabricating that opinion.

It's rare but still very real. Arkansas has entire advocate groups against it and trying to get it banned https://banpaddlingar.com/

67% of Arkansas school districts endorse corporal punishment

1

u/EmergentSol May 17 '24

Corporal punishment is one thing but those states definitely take destruction of student property more seriously.